Wednesday, November 10, 2010

DIVERSITY AND GLOBALISM

The Digital Un-Divide

Suggestions that smart-phone technology has the potential for leveling the digital divide playing field have merit. This potentiality is illustrated in the slavish dependency that individuals have developed for the devices. This attachment is so intense that it has resulted in the nicknaming of the popular Blackberry as the Crackberry.

It is the personal, convenient, and cost-effective ownership of a versatile and powerful handheld that has rendered it the most distributed piece of hardware technology in the world. With the ability to network and download media, it’s no small wonder that academia is touting it as an equalizing educational technology. While I too acknowledge the concepts potential, my validation for it is not without reservation.

Let us assume that the best case scenario is true, that is, that every student owns a 4G smart-phone with the ability to video conference, that it too has all the other 3G phone features that educators feel they could leverage, and that it has administrative permission to be used inside the schools. The potential, no doubt, would be huge, albeit somewhat impractical. You see; while the smartphone will enable maintenance of gender, cultural, and socioeconomic sensitivity, it won’t, on its own, facilitate a student’s acceptance for using it for educational purposes.

In another manner of speaking, there are far too many students that are at risk, exactly because of their diversity, and as a result have developed mindsets that education holds little value in their lives. These casualties of the digital divide will not easily conform to adapting their personal devices neither in, nor outside of, the classroom. While the unencumbered and educationally conscientious student will exhibit little resistance in integrating their personal smartphone within their designed instructional models, these remain in the vast minority.

Fortunately, the features that make the smartphone so attractive to young students can be leveraged in a slightly larger personal device. In my mind the hardware would have to be of a light-weight and portable tablet size smaller than the IPad but bigger than your conventional smartphone. The Galaxy Tab, a product that just hit the market fits all the specifications. The device doubles as one that students could use as they would a smartphone, as well as, an educational tool that would incorporate the necessary functions of a student, i.e., tablet notebook, textbook, word processor, etc.

The resulting combination would be that of a device that a student would want to take care of because of its personal applications and one that he/she would readily see as an advantageous substitute for carrying heavy textbooks and other school supplies. Although the technology would disable all personal applications and functionalities upon entering a school setting, and at once enable connectivity to a Wi-Fi network, at which point it would function exclusively as an educational tool, the disenfranchised student would be compelled to view it as a trendy possession, and would slowly begin to use it for education in the classroom. Using it outside the classroom would follow in due course.

Educators would have immediate digital access to all student work. Student connectivity would be transparent. Attendance, progress (or lack thereof), e-portfolios, and much more could be immediately downloaded onto large databases for all interested stakeholders to evaluate.

While the cost of such a device would be a cause for concern, its allure to parents as a viable educational technology, might convince them that it is a technology worth investing in. If enough do, then prices will go down. If prices go down, we may truly experience a digital un-divide.

Laureate Education, Inc. (Producer). (2008). Diversity and globalism (Video Program), featuring Dr. David Thornburg.
Laureate Education, Inc. (Producer). (2008). The digital divide: Leveling the playing field (Podcast), featuring Dr. Eliot Soloway.

COMMENTED TO SHEILA AND ROBERT.

Monday, November 1, 2010

RED QUEENS & INCREASING RETURNS

The Tale of the Tail

Similar to how DVD technology extinguished VHS formats, video on demand (VOD) is now threatening to do the same to DVDs. Dr. Thornburg has described the former in terms of a disruption, in the sense that DVDs were unexpected, while the latter case seems as a Red Queen Model, where both DVD and VOD are enjoying success with no other competition to be had.

My first choice for watching a movie is always VOD. All fiber-optic television services offer an extensive library of on demand movie offerings. Cost for viewing is based on the age of the movie. Some are available for as low as one dollar (almost to Chris Anderson’s “free stage”). On demand viewing of “Paycheck” cost me $2.95.

Interestingly, while DVDs continue to stock shelves at Costco, on demand offerings are becoming available almost simultaneously with DVD releases to the public. This appears to be identifying a critical mass point, another inflection stage described by Anderson. In other words, DVDs appear as on a precipice and ready to take a steep drop.

But these former accounts are just but a small part of a “long tech tail” indeed. Why it seems like just yesterday that the competition in the high definition optical disc format wars, that is, that between HD DVD and Blue Ray Disc (BD) had declared BD as the winner. A classic case of the “Increasing Returns Model,” where both innovations hit the market at the same time, but by chance one gets locked in (BD) and drives the other (HD DVD) out, its history on this tech tail will be short-lived and anticlimactic by comparison.

The elephant in the room is “the cloud.” The tale of this tech tail would not be complete without talking about the technology that makes on demand and free video, music, communication, and open source in general, possible. Cloud computing is Web-based processing, whereby shared resources, software, and information are provided to computers and other devices on demand. It represents as a paradigm shift away from the client-server technology that relies on a network of servers to facilitate and enable the distribution of information.

In other words, cloud computing is Internet-based and makes information available more efficiently and to a broader audience, while client-server is computer network-based and has certain limitations when compared to “the cloud.” While Wikipedia appears as resolute in describing cloud computing in terms of a paradigm shift, the tale that describes the competition between the two is not so clear.

The client–server model has become one of the central ideas of network computing. Many business applications being written today use the client–server model. So do the Internet's main application protocols, such as HTTP, SMTP, Telnet, and DNS. For now the competition appears as a Red Queen stalemate. The tale of this tech tail is long though. Is there a chance that one technology can get locked in and obsolete the other?

Laureate Education, Inc. (Producer). (2008). Disruptive technologies featuring Dr. David Thornburg.
Laureate Education, Inc. (Producer). (2008). Increasing returns, featuring Dr. David Thornburg.
Laureate Education, Inc. (Producer). (2008). Red queens, featuring Dr. David Thornburg.

COMMENTED TO SUZANNE & MARION.